Quote:
Originally posted by JRutledge
[/B]
|
I really do not know how you got all that information, when he did not say. There was total miscommunication and his partner originally told him that they were shooting two. Now if he originally told him they were shooting two, when did it get discovered that they were shooting one and one? Did the calling official realize he gave his partner the wrong information? Did he report something different to the table than what he told his partner? What happen before the calling official told his partner?
I can assume that you do not know the answer to this, but you seemed to want to throw your hat in this.
[/B][/QUOTE]Not one thing that you just posted above is relevant at all to the original post.Not one thing that you wrote above matters in the least to the way that the play is handled according to the RULES! It is all completely irrelevant.If you think that it is relevant,please tell me exactly why it is,and cite some rules-any rules-to support your reasoning. You stated that this was a correctible error.Please give me a rules citation that will back up that claim.You also said that there was no casebook play covering this situation.A casebook play has been quoted verbatim to you.Again,if you intend to dispute that casebook play,please tell us why,and also post a rules citation that will back up your reasoning.
In other words,Rut,please spell out exactly why Tony and I were wrong on this play,and your answer was correct!