View Single Post
  #18 (permalink)  
Old Mon Apr 04, 2011, 12:14am
Simply The Best Simply The Best is offline
In Time Out
 
Join Date: Mar 2011
Posts: 244
Originally Posted by Simply The Best
Terrible positioning, lazy retreat after going out on catch/no catch; tag on back when scoring R hand and chest are clearly on or past the plate; terrible call.

EJ (hopefully) justified since the player past right by PU. 2nd EJ, if it was loud enough and egregious enough to warrant an EJ, then good on PU.

Quote:
Originally Posted by jicecone View Post
"Terrible positioning"? What was he supposed to do turnaround and run full speed to 3b ext? Don't think so. He has to backpeddle to keep the play in front of him.
You are right, I need to remember that this umpire is being paid according to his expertise and ability. For $75/hr, he has done well. My bad. My umpires earn twice that and are required to pull back and get the up the line vantage point keeping the play in front of them at all times. Which btw, the play bypassed this umpire as the throw passed him well before the slide.
Quote:
Right hand never touched the plate. Did you look at any of the video? First hand to touch was left hand and by then F2 has the tag.
R = runner.
Reply With Quote