Quote:
Originally Posted by dileonardoja
Why would you have R3 scoring if the touch occurs after the MC?
|
There have been many points made since this was asked, but I'll answer why I stated this as my ruling (at least my thoughts at the time)
DDB - if we enforce the penalties for CO and the Balk then we can't also take the play - you get one or the other. The penalty for F2's actions is to award R3 home and B 1B. That is why I had R3 scoring. You can't over look the MC, so EJ after the award.
If we took the result of the play, I'd have him out and EJ b/c the MC was prior to the touch of home.
Note: this was my thinking when I posted. I need to re-read the posts since and decide exactly where I stand.