|
Replying to snagwell:
1) Extends time for losing team. Is that fair?
Perhaps not. Life isn't fair. But consider the team who has 0.2 seconds left to inbound the ball and shoot. Current rules don't allow this so they have been cheated out of some time that _is_ part of the game. The buzzer shot evens up that discrepancy by giving them an outside chance to score.
2) Requires standardized horn sounding (i.e, exactly 3 seconds.)
That is correct. I don't know if that is a big deal or not. If there is a way to do this without requiring new equipment, that would be interesting.
3) The rule is unnecessary.
Yes, but the 3 point shot is similarly unnecessary. I watched a lot of great basketball in my youth before that rule came along. Also please explain to me what problem was solved by allowing dunking.
Good points, really. Thanks for responding!
Rock
|