Quote:
Originally Posted by Eastshire
Snaq, are you saying this would be a legal play?
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Camron Rust
I wouldn't. Even if the rules do not expressly prohibit it, it is an advantage not intended by the rules.
We have at least a few case plays that establish that when a player who is holding the ball deliberately releases the ball such that it is not a dribble, a try, or a pass, they are effectively considered to have been holding the ball the entire time as far as the traveling rules are concerned when they again pick up the ball.
|
Exactly. The only differences between this and the "sets the ball down" play are that the ball rolls (and who's to say it isn't rolling slightly in the book play) and we're talking pivot foot restrictions rather than getting up.
The difference between my play and Billy's play is that Billy's player loses control and fumbles. If a player lying on the floor fumbles it, he can then get up and retrieve it.