Quote:
Originally Posted by BktBallRef
Then you're making up your own rules.  |
Sorry, I'm quoting you, but the first sentence below refers to the other poster:
Read the case play again. What I said was, "If the horse collar is what brings the runner down....."
In A, he doesn't go down and in B he doesn't go down from the HC. Where are we saying anything different?
What I'm saying is that contact from a second person doesn't absolve the person with the hand in the cookie jar from a HC penalty if that's what brings the runner down.