Quote:
Originally Posted by topper
I'm not sure how far behind I'd be, unless they neither slide nor slow up into the bag. That slight risk is by far out weighed by having more of the entire sequence in front of me. Besides, PU doesn't have anything left to do.
|
Assuming there are no other runners, taking the last runner to 3B should always be the BU's responsibility. PU should be preparing for a play at the plate. Priorities.
Quote:
Originally Posted by topper
When working ASA it's a moot point.
|
But we're not talking about keeping what this association or that association wants. We're talking about what WE want as officials. So no, it's not a moot point.
Quote:
Originally Posted by topper
When not, I would think the more advanced official would suggest doing some things differently and explaining why. That's what we do at every camp I've been a part of.
|
That can be dangerous if done with a truly inexperienced umpire. You'd have to pre-game it extensively and in an environment where you can afford to make those adjustments. Doing this in the finals would be bad timing.
Not to mention the fact that first and foremost, our main concern as veteran umpires tasked with bringing up the rookies is to give them the building blocks from which to grow. By starting off doing something different from the prescribed mechanics, you're not doing them any favors as a mentor.
Quote:
Originally Posted by topper
You're still talking only about seeing the play at second. The discussion is about keeping everything in front of you.
|
Yes, and we should be ready for subsequent plays. Never compromise getting a good look at a play if it means getting behind the runner at your next play. It may work for 9 out of 10 plays, but it's that 10th play that'll bite you in the @$$.
Quote:
Originally Posted by topper
I quess your UIC doesn't mind if the PU just hangs out at home. Maybe someone should explain to him/her, and you for that matter, that the subsequent play at 3rd should be covered by the PU.
|
Yes, the PU and BU are a team. And it's a team that works in priorities. As far as I'm concerned, the priorities on the bases start with home plate and work their way backwards. This is why the BU takes the trailing plays at 3rd, as well as the last runner or batter-runner. A blown call at 2nd or 3rd doesn't sting quite so badly as a blown call at home plate.
Quote:
Originally Posted by topper
Unfortunately, since I do live in the Houston area, this wouldn't surprise me of some of the UICs/assignors I know.
|
Won't even touch this one with a 10 foot pole, especially considering there are involved parties present on this board.