Quote:
Originally Posted by topper
I would move inside and head to 3rd.
|
Yes, but now you've got some catching up to do because you're trailing the runner, which is the absolute worst place to be when making a call.
Quote:
Originally Posted by topper
Being out of the way is fine, but you will not have as much in front of you, nor be able to see the play develop. Plus you will not be in as good of a position to see the play at second because you are "out of the way".
|
Actually, I don't have a problem seeing it develop. If the ball is at the plate, I know I need to be off to one side or another on a baseline. If the runner has already touched 2B, I should be closer to baseline between 1B and 2B, ready to cover 3B if necessary. If the runner is coming from 1B into 2B, I should be closer to the baseline between 2B and 3B.
In both of those cases, I have an easy time of getting a good 90º to the tag, and I don't have nearly as much distance to cover if the runner should I need to cover 3B.
Quote:
Originally Posted by topper
I agree. ASA does not. I think that was Wade's point.
|
I understand both sides to the coin: ASA needs to get almost 50k umpires (according to their website) up-to-speed with good techniques, but there are other advanced ways of covering plays.
The problem comes when you have an advanced umpire with an inexperienced one. Whose mechanics should dictate the other's behavior?