Quote:
Originally Posted by wanja
There is a difference between the NCAA and NFHS rules that I was unaware of. While the NCAA allows a pivot foot in the cited situation, the NFHS does not.
|
THe difference is NOT what you seem to be saying it is. In fact, both rules agree. These two rules are NOT talking about the same situation
Let's label the actions that are occuring as follows:
A = Airborne
C = Catch the ball
O = Landing on and Jumping from one foot
T = Land on two feet
P = Pivot
Quote:
Originally Posted by wanja
NCAA Rule 4
Section 44. Jump Stop
A jump stop may also be executed when the dribbler has one foot on the playing court, initiates a jump off that foot, ends the dribble with both feet off the playing court and lands simultaneously on both feet (either foot can be established as the pivot foot).
|
This situation, using my labels as defined above, is
A - O - A -
C - A - T - P (pivot is
legal here)
Quote:
Originally Posted by wanja
NFHS Rule 4
Section 44. Traveling
Article 2. A player who catches the ball while moving or dribbling, may stop and establish a pivot foot as follows
a. If both feet are off the floor and the player lands:
3. On one foot, the palyer may jump off that foot and simultaneously land on both. Neither foot can be a pivot in that case.
|
This situation, using my labels as defined above, is
A -
C - A - O - A - T - P (pivot is
illegal here)
Note that the point of the "Catch" is different between these two.
One has the ball being caught after the jump from one foot (pivot allowed) where the other has the ball being caught before the jump (no pivot allowed).
Both sequences are judged the same in both rule sets...they're just written a bit differently.