[rwest]

Originally Posted by AtlUmpSteve

I think you are confusing different issues.

The obstructed runner is ALWAYS awarded the base the umpire judges the runner would have reached if not obstructed. That decision is to be made at the time of the obstruction, and is not subject to subsequent plays or misplays.

If/when an obstructed runner is put out between the bases obstructed, or prior to the protected base (the test is BOTH, not either/or), THEN you declare a dead ball, award the obstructed runner the appropriate base, and judge OTHER runners based on the halfway rule at the time of the dead ball (although, they cannot force the obstructed runner either forward or backwards). The obstructed runner can push another runner, but not vice versa.

With the sole exception of the NCAA special "rounding or returning" obstruction rule, I believe all of the above is the same in NFHS and NCAA.

Steve,

In all the clinics I've been to, I've never heard this halfway rule in regards to awarding bases to NON-Obstructed runners. Where does this mechanic come from?