Quote:
Originally Posted by w_sohl
OK, I think you may have misunderstood what I was saying. And that possibly could have bben because I didn't word it properly.
No shot, put 1.5 back on the clock.
With a shot attempted that doesn't end till after the SC horn sounds, you are going to have to use some judgement. You aren't going to put 1.5 back on the clock. You are only going to put what you have definite knowledge of back on. If you or your partners didn't look at the clock when you blew your whistle, then period is over. If you or they did, then you'll have definite knowledge of how much time to put back on the clock.
|
I agree with the part in blue.
I still don't know of any rules support, even from the state of CA, for what is in red.
My take is that if there is no shot and the horn sounds at 1.5, but the whistle doesn't sound to recognize that violation until 1.1, then by rule you have to leave 1.1 on the game clock. I know of nothing stating that this situation is different from a traveling violation. You don't go with the time that the violation occurred, you go with the time when the whistle sounded.
That seems to be where you and I differ. Now if you can prove otherwise, that's great and I will have learned something.