Quote:
Originally Posted by kdf5
First, if I were going to listen to someone on this board, you'd be the last person. As far as what I've offered, what I did was quote the exact rule, word for word, not my opinion. The rule for roughing specifically says after it is clear the ball has been thrown. Therefore if a hit on the passer is legal in its timing but has a PF aspect to it, like the original play, it is a PF, not roughing.
As usual, you've dodged the details, you've filled the pages with your crap and I know for a fact that since I've been on this forum you have dodged every question I've ever posed to you and you've dodged them because your answer to my questions would have proven you wrong. Hearing you say you're open minded and will consider new evidence is total BS. You are on here for one reason only and that is to sling crap at others who disagree with you.
The only one on here barking that they're right is you. No one else has disputed my posts but you. No one. The sad thing is that you aren't but you're not man enough to nut up and admit it. I don't need to join your club. I'm in my 3rd decade of doing this. The only thing I need to understand from you is that you're a nut job.
|
I'm sorry you've had such a bad experience trying to explain yourself kdf5, but whining about it isn't going to provide much solace. I don't know what details you think I've dodged, and I think you missed an important point, I am open to suggestion, but only when the person making the suggestion appears to know what he's talking about and is willing and able to make his point, which you haven't even attempted to do, thus far. You just seem somewhat hung up on this "I'm right, you're wrong" stuff that really isn't all that important, because nobody, or at least most, bothers to keep score.
I've tried to ignore your nit picking before, on a number of issues, because most times it's just not anything worth arguing about, but here there's a serious penalty differential, so it does make a difference. I remember back when I was in my 3rd decade of officiating, and I don't recall being so inflexible or easily offended.