Quote:
Originally Posted by Corndog89
The partner, who BTW was trail and thus it was his call to make (or in this case, blow) called a violation...he got it wrong, but he called a violation nonetheless.
|
I asked jar this question, and never got a response. I'll ask you too: What is your definition of an indavertant/accidental whistle, in the context of the rules? Surely it's a little more than the official sneezing and the whistle blowing as a result? What about the case play Nevada posted about the official being sure there was a TO request, but got it wrong and called the TO nonetheless? How does the committee consider that an accidental whistle, but the OP's play is not?
If this whole issue is about overruling a partner's call, remember the OP said:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Smitty
When I go over and ask what he's doing, he has the deer in the headlights look. He realizes he's kicked it, but now what do we do?
|
The original question was about the official who made the call realized they blew it and made a call they should not have, so what does the crew do now? It has never been about correcting a partner's wrong call.