Speaking ASA
Don't try to out-think the rules, it isn't worth it the headache or attempt to justify a rule which does not exist. Use the rules that are there.
The rule previously cited clearly states that the pitcher must have a foot in contact with the PP. If, in your judgment, the pitcher is not in contact, then it is an IP.
However, considering the conditions of many of the fields I've worked and seen, I can appreciate the pitcher's concern and I have no problem with a pitcher covering up the PP as long as I believe the pitcher met the prerequisite for a legal pitch.
To me, this is a booger not worth seeking out unless you have reason to do so.
|