I watched the video several times and it's pretty inconclusive. It never really shows where the runner was in relation to second base when the outfielder releases the throw.
You're right though - The announcers had no clue. Big surprise.
On a related note, they had an ex-player doing the color commentary for the Cubs/Cardinals on WGN yesterday...can't remember his name. He parroted the old "Tie goes to the runner" myth after a play during the game.
|