A lot is said to new umpires about trusting their equipment so that they don't flinch or turn away from a pitch coming in but very little is ever said about trusting your eyes.
I have been watching some games recently with some umpires who have what it takes to be good umpires. While watching these games, I am seeing a disturbing trend of umpires not using their eyes or not trusting those same eyes.
Now, these games have been in 3 different states, within different organizations but almost all of them are ASA trained umpires. Four of the umpires work NCAA for sure, I am not sure about the rest.
One tourney was ISA, another NSA the other two were ASA local events.
When you are working the plate, almost everyone who reads this knows to get your self set for the pitch etc etc etc.
However, what I am seeing is a real lack of using the eyes to make sure it is legal to even have a pitch or if a ball was hit legally.
For instance:
1.) Having a coach on the field of play. The ball was made live and a pitch was delivered. Luckily for the umps, the ball was hit foul.
2.) F3 was not on the field of play but was over by her dugout. This is an illegal pitch. Refer to your rule books.
3.) The batter did not have both feet in the box at any time prior to the start of the pitch. This situation occured over and over at all the games I watched. The batter had not and was not delaying.
The umpires were ringing up strikes and had no idea of where the batter was. This was not a quick pitch type of situation either. Just pi$$ poor game management.
5.) Batters stepping back and out of the box then re-entering the box to hit the ball.
DEAD BALL, BATTER IS OUT
6.) Batters out of the box when they hit the ball. I am talking one foot completely out of the box, not touching a line and ON THE GROUND out of the box when contact was made.
DEAD BALL, BATTER IS OUT. This was so blatent in one game that you could clearly see the batters foot print in the freshly prepped field at least two feet, 24 inches, out in front of the plate.
All of the umps I saw had really good strike zones, their mechanics were pretty good too.
If you wonder why coaches are going nuts, these easy calls are one of the reasons.
Guys and ladies, you have to fulfill your duties at the plate.
One of the big duties is to SEE what is happening out there and to enforce the rules fairly, without prejudice. The reason for the rules is to NOT ALLOW an unfair advantage.
If you are working your slot well, you can see that foot out of the box. If you cant' see it, you aren't trusting your equipment or you are lazy.
We have all talked to death the need to see our strike zone well, to get that low outside pitch and ring it up.
Just as important is to see what is there before and during the pitch.
Sure, it is kinda cheesy to call a ball because F4 is delaying the pitch past the 20 second limit. But that is the coaches responsibility to correct it. I promise that if you call it early, the coaches are going to want to know why and it will get fixed quickly.
The batter has to be in the box PRIOR to the start of the pitch and cannot step out and re-enter to hit the pitch.
If you cannot see that a batters foot is out of the box and on the ground while watching the pitch, then maybe you aren't as good an umpire as you think you are.
Peripheral vision has a lot to do with this and you need to exercise that portion of your skills. You can see it unless you are not in position.
I used to be teased a long time ago about calling the foot on the ground out of the box when the pitch was hit and game films supported me everytime it was available.
Make the call, just as we say about a pitch......"Every ball deserves a call." Everything about the game is worth having a call made on it. Most however require nothing to be said but you have to know what is going on.
We check bats, we check this we check that.
Pay attention to details, that is what you are getting paid to do.
Now, I don't want to leave the impression that the umps I saw were terrible, they weren't. Not at all.
They had a lot of hustle, good positioning. They sold their calls when needed. The strike zones were excellent with not a complaint as far as I could tell from the coaches or catchers.
They dealt with the coaches really well, right up until a coach came out on the issues I listed above.
Then, I could see the umps eyes glaze over and they became overly officious. One even told a coach, "I will worry about what goes on in front of me you take care of your team." The coach was not rude and was actually much more pleasant than I thought he was going to be.
I was close enough to be able to hear the conversation as they had moved off to the side away from the plate and I was able to clearly see the infractions I listed above.
We all joke about how much better the fans think they can see the game from outside the fence and we actually deride them for what they think they saw. I know, becuase I am world class at this, calling them "howler monkeys" etc.
But what I am seeing lately, I am beginning to think that a lot of what they think they see, they really do.
I have been around a long time with ASA, ISF (not as long) and other sports.
You have to train your eyes to see what is supposed to be there so you will recognize it when something isn't right.
You need to have confidence on the field, you work on knowing the rules, you work to make your uniform look sharp, you concentrate on your strike zone, you work to make sure you can clear the catcher etc etc.
Work on your eyes, and make sure you are seeing ALL that you are supposed to see.
Don't be arrogant but be sure. Being confident and knowing you have the call won't make you popular but it will let a coach or a player that their game matters and you aren't there just to get a check.