Quote:
Originally Posted by ILMalti
As I said before NO count in Camron situation since they did not face each other. Sitiation 9.10.1C quite clearly says when a count has to be started. The "closely guarded" count rule is in Rule 9 not rule 4.10.
As you know the interpretations and rulings for all play situations have been approved by the rules committee and are "OFFICIAL"
Therefore please read situation 9.10.1c when a count should start and explain to me how camrons example fits is.
|
It doesn't....but it doesn't need to. As I said, this case mentions what is sufficient to get a count but it doesn't say that it is necessary. Two very different things.
.....
Quote:
Originally Posted by ILMalti
now for Cameron
Please read rule 9.10.1b The situation you site (9.10.1D) is specific for that rule We are discussing 9.10.1A... Good try 
|
Note that 9.10.1B says "In the situation outlined..." That expressly means the comments that follow are targeted at that very situation and are not intended to establish a general requirement.
9.1.1D is mentioned to disprove the claim that LGP is required for a CG count. And it does just that.
We're talking about the definition of CG vs. LGP. You've yet to cite one rule/case that says says CG requires LGP...only that LGP within 6' satisfies the requirement for CG.