Quote:
Originally Posted by rsl
At a high school camp with NFHS rules.
A1 has control of the ball in the frontcourt. B1 knocks the
ball loose. A2 knocks the ball so B1 can't grab it, then chases
it down in back court.
I whistle back court violation. First one I have ever called on
the "last to touch - first to touch" rule.
Coach yells at me. At next time out, D2 evaluator tells me I
messed up because team control ended on B1's tap. I say
"yes sir" to the evaluator and smile.
4-12-3 says team control continues until opponent secures control.
9-9-1 says this is backcourt violation
What good is being right if nobody knows? 
Or, did I kick this call and I am still clueless? |
Quote:
Originally Posted by ILMalti
Yes you are right they are one and the same, I really was trying to get an understanding of the position of B1 and the ball after B1 "knocks the ball"
At times the ball/feet on the line is/are overlooked, hence the question.
Regardless, i believe the answers are important to determine the call. No?
|
Based on the OP, "A2 knocks the ball so B1 can't grab it, then chases
it down in back court." This tells me, intuitively, that they are both starting from the front court. Whether the ball bounces on the line or completely in the BC isn't relevant, I don't think. I would agree that A2 and B1's positioning is important, but I think it's safely implied from the OP that they were both in the FC.