Forget that crap about the aquarium. The ball must break the plane of the goal line.
From Peter King's column, si.com
Steelers continue to survive in tough games - Peter King - SI.com
After the game, Coleman told a pool reporter that Holmes "had two feet down and completed the catch
with control of the ball breaking the plane of the goal line ...
When he gained control of the ball, the ball was breaking the plane, and then he fell into the field of play. But to have a touchdown, all you have to have is a catch, which is the two feet down, possession and control of the ball breaking the plane."
I called NFL vice president of officiating
Mike Pereira, who'd spoken with Coleman and the replay assistant following the game. Now, I have to tell you that in my jobs at NBC and
Sports Illustrated I have occasion to speak with Pereira nearly every weekend about a play or two from the games, either to clarify something for the
Football Night in America show or for my column. Pereira calls them the way he sees them. My experience is that Pereira does not whitewash a bad call. And last night, I asked him point blank if he thought there was indisputable visual evidence that the ball broke the plane of the goal line. "Yes, I do,'' he said.