Quote:
Originally Posted by just another ref
We knew all that. So why cite this rule when saying fighting during a live ball can be a personal?
|
As far as I know I didn't, but for some reason you claim that I did. I actually cited 8.7 Situation A.
Quote:
Originally Posted by just another ref
Interesting that you and JR use this rule to make the point that your are making. 4-18-2 does not specify personal or technical, and 4.18.2 situation is one where a personal foul call is certainly not an option.
|
I merely quoted a post by JR from another thread in which there was a discussion about whether or not certain action qualified as fighting. That is why he quoted the definition of fighting within his post. I quoted his post because he also stated therein his belief of the proper penalty for fighting during a live ball--flagrant personal foul. That is the line that I really cared about.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee
"Personally, I think I'd call that a "fight" and give both players flagrant personal fouls for fighting."
|