Quote:
Originally Posted by Nevadaref
I never said that it was fair.
|
Let me see...no,....nothing there....no......nope. Nowhere did I say that you said it was fair. I simply made my own observation.
Quote:
|
I just said that BY RULE the player has scored a legal goal, and that there is no rules support for cancelling that.
|
No, he has not scored a legal goal. The ball is dead when he rebounds it. It makes no difference whether he shoots it, double dribbles it, or throws it OOB. The case play is clear, at least to most eveyone else. There's nothing magical about shooting a dead ball.
Quote:
This is similar toh the discussion that we had last year about the FT shooter losing the ball and then stepping into the lane to chase after it BEFORE an official sounded a whistle. Even you said that was a violation on the shooter BY RULE. Here is a link to that thread:
Free Throw Violation
|
Wrong again, Tutts. This is a live ball situation. The whistle is required to kill the play.
The OP is a dead ball sitaution.
Of course, that debate is now moot due to the new part b of 9.1.1.
Quote:
|
PS Please note that I did not suggest that Team A be allowed to keep the basket.
|
You didn't?
Then, what does this suggest?
"Without that happening, I don't see how the basket can be cancelled."
Make up your mind.