Quote:
|
Originally Posted by BillyMac
2007-08 NFHS Point Of Emphasis:
2) Free Throws. The NFHS Basketball Rules Committee continues to be concerned about activities surrounding free throws, especially rough play.
A. Rough Play. Keeping the block between the players continues to serve its initial purpose. The same is true for player restrictions ending when the attempt hits the ring. Coaches must not teach players to "lock up" arms along the lane line, nor drive players farther under the basket with brute force. Offensive players in the second position must not be permitted to displace or push the defensive player in the first lane position. In addition, defensive players in the last position should not be permitted to displace the free throw shooter. Fouls must be called for illegal contact and displacement on free throws, just as they would for illegal rebounding activity off of any try.
B. Lane Positioning. There has been much debate on what, if anything, to do with lane positioning on free throws. Some want rules that would players up on the low block or even eliminate the first lane space. The belief is that the players underneath the basket are at a rebounding disadvantage. Data collected from a variety of sources does not support that belief. Multiple studies show players in the first marked lane spaced garner approximately 75-80 percent of all free throws rebounds. That is a range the rules committee finds acceptable and is consistent with historical norms. The team closest to the basket is supposed to get most of the rebounds, not be guaranteed a rebound. The rules in that case are also not designed to give each team an equal chance at securing a rebound.
C. Violations. Players are attempting to gain a rebounding advantage by violating the free throw restrictions and entering the lane early. Officials must review and enforce the rules regarding offensive and defensive free throw violations.
I guess that new data, collected from a greater variety of new sources, and new multiple studies, showed that players in the first marked lane spaced garnered less than 75-80 percent of all free throws rebounds, a range the rules committee finds unacceptable, and inconsistent, with historical norms???
|
I call BS. I don't agree that 80% of the time, the D ends up with the rebound in the old system. Mind you, I don't have "many studies" - but just my experience.
You mentioned before that you've done 27 seasons. Surely in that time you've figured the Fed out.
C. I am a stickler for things like this, and I only call 1-2 FTLV(s) per season. In my opinion, the Fed's concern doesn't have a leg to stand on, for games that I do.
A. Like I said, I have few fouls on rebounds. I see lots of A players getting around B players for the ball. More than 20% for sure. I don't remember seeing players locking arms, and especially driving opponents further under the basket.
I think you trust the NFHS too much. Just my 2 cents.