Quote:
|
Originally Posted by mu4scott
I'm talking about this specific play. It's very clear that she leans into her and should be called for an illegal screen. Is anyone disputing that?
|
Nope, what's being disputed is the relevance of any other criteria that have been brought up; score, time, player's skill, whether you can explain it to a coach, game management., etc.
If you think she stepped into the contact, it's a foul. If you don't think she stepped in, it's a no-call. Game management has nothing to do with it. GM might call for an intentional if you think it was illegal (although I'm backing down from that one now) and excessive. GM might call for an IW to give her a second to recover. GM might call for an explanation to the coach of what you saw. GM may call for simply no whistle.
Here's the problem with bringing GM up here to defend why you have to make a call; you don't know how GM fits in from watching only one play.