Jim:
Absent an unamed, retired umpire who would never had seen such a play, you will most likely remain a lone voice. I exclude Boone from your company, because he seems to think the ball is live, while you understand it is dead, but would call a balk anyway.
In the past you have been a devotee of J/R and JEA. What say they about this?
Reverse your reasoning. Show me the rule that allows the call of a balk during a dead ball and you will have convert.
GB
|