I noticed you didn't ask her about the situation where a punch is thrown but no contact is made. By rule, there's no way this can be called a personal foul. It has to be a technical. I don't care what her title is, if she can't understand that, then she's in the wrong job.
She most certainly should make editorial changes to 10-3-10 if she wants a personal foul called for fighting. Solidify the rule to match the interps in the case book and things will work fine.
|