As soon as I saw the OP, I knew that Goodman would be making those points, including the 0th down. I should have made them first to look smart.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Robert Goodman
Heh. The funny thing is that if you go into the early 20th Century, offside pass was the only foul as that word was then used in Canadian football.
|
Can you expand on this?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Robert Goodman
But Fed doesn't define "where the runner is positioned" in relation to a particular part of the body, and if you're releasing a ball, some part of the runner's body must be touching it and hence at the same yard line.
|
I made this same point when I was picked up by the Canadian NCAA equivalent.
I also made the point that since a handoff is all about ball position in Cdn ball (as everything is), the point of origin and point of termination of a handoff pass are always the same, due to the physical nature of releasing a ball when another has shared control with you. If the two points are always the same, there never really is a forward handoff, therefore never an illegal handoff. The definition needs to be cleaned up.