BktBallRef, Your quote below;
Quote:
Originally posted by BktBallRef
The case book and the rule book seem to have a bit of a contradiction. There's a case play that calls live ball fighting a flagrant personal foul. But the rule book says that fighting is a T, and it doesn't differentiate between live ball and dead ball. [/B]
|
I looked all through the case book and can't find where they use the rule incorretly. In ever situation I found, live ball fighting was flagrant personal and then dead ball was flagrant technical. This being correct according to the rules.
The rule book 10-3-9, the way I am reading is a dead ball. Fighting being engagement between two or more people. The first punch thrown, if no reataliation is not a fight. So one player punches another that is flagrant personal. The retaliation is flagrant technical and any subsequent punches are fighting and are flagrant technical. That is the way I am reading it.