how's this not a strike?
Marty has quoted the definition of a STRIKE from OBR. The kid swung the bat at a pitched ball. He did not make contact with the pitch. Thus this is a strike. Period.
Umpire judgement is based on the observation of facts as the situation of develops. Facts being the key word. By attempting to define intent you cross over into the world of speculation. Maybe the kid wasn't all that bright and thought he could snag a hit (don't laugh, I've seen it).
Aren't there only 2 instances where an umpire can make a judgement based on his perception of the player's intent? 1 being in ruling a balk and 2 being malicious contact.
I'm kind of new at this, but wasn't this a blown call?
__________________
Alan Roper
Stand your ground. Don't fire unless fired upon, but if they mean to have a war, let it begin here - CPT John Parker, April 19, 1775, Lexington, Mass
|