REPLY: Coach Bryan...I don't believe anyone here doubts that you did the proper research on this new formation, and that the NF and your state association was thorough in its review of the legality of the A11. But one thing to remember is this: Many, many rules in Federation, NCAA, and even the NFL come about because well-meaning, innovative people learn the rules and "push the envelope." While what you're doing is perfectly legal, there is indeed the possibility that once it's observed and the Federation determines that it unduly disrupts the competitive balance between offense and defense, they may very well take steps to restrict it's use. For rulesmakers, maintaining that competitive ballance is the primary driver for rule changes.
__________________
Bob M.
|