|
Not sure what else can be said. You are mixing things up too much and trying to take the effective result of an enforcement and saying that it equates to a live ball foul being penalized as a dead ball foul. But the fallacy in doing that is that you are ignoring the specific language in certain rules that makes the enforcement in certain situations somewhat outside the norm.
As for your PF against a player out of the play, you and your crew have to make a decision as to when that foul took place. If you decide it happened after the ball became dead, enforce as a dead ball foul. If it happened while live, then enforce as a live ball foul. The argument over this situation has been discussed pretty well on the various discussion boards. You CANNOT say that foul happened while the ball was live and enforce it as a dead ball foul. There is NO way the rules provide for that.
If you do not think it is unreasonable to create your own penalty enforcements then there really is not much need to even discuss further.
|