Quote:
|
Originally Posted by GarthB
Forget the box.
Take a runner coming down the third base line who gets hit by a batted ball. What determines if he is out or not...the position of one foot, or the position of the ball and body part when he is hit?
|
But if we "forget the box" we won't be able to make any sensible call on this play!
Being struck while either in or out of the box is what determines the difference between a foul ball and the batter being called out. So we had best not forget about it.
In your analogy, the fair or foul status of the ball as it hits the runner is clearly defined by rule and that rule can be verified by anybody with a rule book.
A batter being struck by his own batted ball while still in the batter's box is covered by interpretation- an interpretation that conflicts with other written rules and appears in materials not readily available to the general public.
Other posters have stated that they have the "official interpretation". I suppose that "because I said so" might fly, but let's pretend I'm from Missouri.
Show me!