i feel like you are missing the point of the post. the fact that the batter is out is not in question. the guy was simply stating that while the OP was an odd situation, in his game there was an even more odd situation in which a batter was called out strikes twice in the same game on pitches that hit him. maybe he was leaning over the plate, maybe the PU stunk...PU. maybe he should have put a smiley face on his post or something.