[GarthB]

Originally Posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.

jicecone:

Now you are changing the play, of course the play you described at the end of you last sentence is a balk. Taking a sign from the catcher anybody else while not in contact with the pitcher's plate is not a balk. Two different plays which are not even remotely similiar.

MTD, Sr.

No, he didn't change the play...you didn't read what you reponded to, even though you "quoted" it in your post.

Originally Posted by GarthB

I'm surprised with your vast experience you haven't seen that move.

I've seen it with RH pitchers in contact and called it a balk several times in California, New York and, yep, in good ol' Spokane.

In fact, I called it in an MSBL game last Sunday.

Then you wrote:

Originally Posted by MTD

Garth:

And I am sorry to have to tell you, but you were wrong in California, New York, Spokane, and last Sunday.

MTD, Sr.

I think you were just too eager to dismiss anything I may have written.