Quote:
|
Originally Posted by mbyron
Have to disagree here, Bob. The infractions penalized for a balk are listed in 6-2-4, and taking signals off the rubber is not listed there.
The relevant rule is 6-1-1, and the relevant sentence is:
The penalty listed in 6-1-1 is for an illegal pitch, which as you know occurs only if the pitcher quick pitches.
I don't see how you can justify calling a balk for this, even under FED.
|
Read Bob's post again. He very carefully separated the two parts of the move contained in the OP and then describe to different manners in which the first part could be accomplished.
What he is calling a balk by rule, I believe, is a pitcher simulating motions associated with pitch while not in contact with the rubber.