Quote:
|
Originally Posted by crazy voyager
...these are [...] points to make it easier for officials to learn what is a bc and what's not, they're not the rulebook.
|
That is exactly the point which I am striving to make with these two plays. For NFHS and NCAA, we have this nice four-point checklist, but it is not a true substitute for the text of the rule. When one wants to really get the facts, one must go to the actual text.
The danger with using the four-point system is that one may try apply it when it is inappropriate to do so.
For example, the second point has been phrased as, "The player or a teammate was the last to touch the ball before it went to the backcourt." This criterion could be met without the player or teammate ever touching the ball
in the frontcourt as is clearly required by 9-9-1. Thus the checklist would give a false positive.
The same could be said for the wording of the third point with regard to the backcourt and article 9-9-2.