Originally Posted by
fitump56
[
Originally Posted by bob jenkins
Review (of umpire's performance by a qualified reviewer or group): Yes.
Instant Review (in a panacea to "get the call right"): Generally no.
|
In no instance would you support IR, none? Not even for a Reviewer who could be at the field performing both as your Reviewer and Play Reviewer? (think College Football)
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by bob jenkins
1) We're talking about baseball, not college football.
|
We are talking IR where the game is stopped and, possibly, a limited number of IRs are awarded each game. You know that, don't be disingenuos.
Quote:
2) I said "generally" not "in no instance". The only time I can think of that it might be used is fair/foul on a "home run" -- where the ball is dead either way.
|
Then you need to think harder. I have listed several that make perfect sense, one would be a catch-no catch, 2 out, where the determination would be a catch and all Rs would not be allowed to advance.