Let me see if I understand this correctly.
The title of this thread is
Critique Please
CraigD explains in pretty good detail a situation he had in an adult league game. Seemingly, he would like to be critiqued on the way he handled the situation.
Many critiques are given, and most are along the lines of, "You should have warned or ejected soon. You let the situation go too far."
Then CraigD defends his actions to the
nth degree.
Me thinks he wanted verification, not an honest critique. I've seen that kind of umpire before.
