Quote:
|
Originally Posted by WestMichBlue
Come on, Mr. ASA - you are denying what your own people have written. Someone somewhere in ASA heirarchy deliberately wrote that it is illegal to hit the ball on a second swing. There has to be a reason (does there really?) for ASA to write that statement.
|
Which has what to do with the point that the issue under discussion is that there wasn't two swings?
Quote:
|
On a 60 mph pitch that reaches the plate in less than a half second, there is no way in hell that a batter can wait until "the ball was actually there for the bat to strike" and swing twice and actually hit the ball. Obviously, the swing has to start early so as to get the bat around a second time. Fact is, the bat swing has to start before the pitch is even released.
|
Thank you for proving the point. How can the initial movement of the bat be considered a swing if the ball hasn't even been released yet?
Quote:
And if the batter is really good enough to hit the ball on the second swing, ASA says that is illegal - strike on the batter and return base runners.
WBM
|
Again, this is not the discussion. My part of this discussion has been completely along the premise of what constitutes a swing, not that there was more than one.