View Single Post
  #54 (permalink)  
Old Mon Jun 11, 2007, 02:59pm
Scrapper1 Scrapper1 is offline
Lighten up, Francis.
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 4,690
Quote:
Originally Posted by WIRef
Wouldn't the second throw-in be considered part of the original AP throw-in because of the kick, and when that throw-in is "legally" completed, the arrow would then change?
No, WIRef. Here's what I wrote previously in this thread:

Quote:
Since the AP throw-in didn't end, the arrow is not switched. The next throw-in is NOT an AP throw-in. It is the result of the kick. Since it's not an AP throw-in, the arrow does not come into play at all. After the kick, there is simply a designated spot throw-in, and the arrow will not change.

Quote:
This tells us to switch the arrow is the throw-in team violates, not to switch for a foul by either team, but doesn't instruct in the case of a defensive team violation.
That's because the defensive violation carries its own penalty, which does not involve the AP arrow.
Here's what Jurassic wrote:

Quote:
What is the penalty for a kicked ball?

Answer: a throw-in for the other team.

The AP is a non-factor. Changing the arrow is not part of the kicked-ball penalty.
Here's what BktBallRef wrote:

Quote:
An AP throw-in occurs after a held ball situation, not after the ball is kicked.
Sensing a theme? The penalty for a kicked ball is a designated spot throw-in. The penalty for a kicked ball is NOT an AP throw-in. The AP throw-in never ended, so the arrow never switched.