View Single Post
  #2 (permalink)  
Old Sat May 12, 2007, 11:57pm
JEL JEL is offline
Official Forum Member
 
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 910
Quote:
Originally Posted by tribefan1952
I wasn't there. The losing pitcher's father caught up to me at work the next day and asked me what I thought...

JV game. 2 out. Bottom of 7th. R1 on 1st. Dropped 3rd strike. Ump, working alone, says batter's OUT! Players leave the field. Catcher rolls ball back to pitcher's mound. Batter runs to 1st.

Teams line up to shake hands. Home coach argues ruling. Ump realizes she screwed up. Allows batter to go to 1st. Game resumes (after plenty of discussion). Naturally, the home team scores a couple runs and wins the game.

The pitcher's father was pretty cool about it. He just wanted my opinion. I told him that once the batter is called out, she's out. This ruling can't be changed.

Is it the catcher's job to go ahead and make the play after the ump made the wrong call?

> I told him that once the batter is called out, she's out. This ruling can't be changed.<

Well, yes it could be be changed. The umpire does have authority to "rectify" a call such as this, but.........

>Home coach argues ruling.<

Well duh, I would too!

but.......

> Players leave the field<
>Teams line up to shake hands. Home coach argues ruling.<

Timing a bit off, defense has left the field, game over.

Last edited by JEL; Sun May 13, 2007 at 12:05am.
Reply With Quote