View Single Post
  #8 (permalink)  
Old Sat Apr 21, 2007, 01:53pm
David B David B is offline
Official Forum Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Mississippi
Posts: 1,772
Not always true

Quote:
Originally Posted by Coach Jinx
Most of you clowns never ask for help...if you do ask you must be a football official also. I had a game last week where on of my friends(a guy I let sub last year on my football crew)was working the plate. We had a close play on a slow hit ball to short where it appeared to me from the 3rd base box that he pulled his foot. The BU called him out & I thought he pulled his foot. I didnt ask for an appeal because I wanted to see what would happen. I watch my HL a couple of days earlier ask for help on the same play. The BU who didn/t ask for help is just a baseball guy. After the inning I asked my friend if the 1st baseman pulled his foot & he said "if I would of appealed he would of said yes he pulled his foot". THAT IS WHY I DON'T LIKE BASEBALL AS MUCH AS FOOTBALL OFFICIATING. BASEBALL WILL LET SOMETHING WRONG GO ON WHEN FOOTBALL WON'T.
No true, that's why football has "INSTANT REPLAY" and baseball doesn't!

You can correct things retroactively in football without affecting the play. That is not true in baseball.

As stated, the BU should be smart enought to know if there is a chance F3 was off the bag - then quickly ask before making the call.

Once he makes the call as out then its too late.

I know he was your friend as PU, but you never tell a coach, "if he would have asked I would have said he pulled his foot." That undermines the whole crew.

Thanks
David