[jkumpire]

Well,

This has been an interesting discussion! I brought the subject up because I am a local FED rules interpreter, and I still find myself in a quandry about the rule.

Why? Because this discussion has missed one point about the rule. The rule as writen was put in as a safety rule. If it is a safety rule, then we have an obligation to enforce it whether or not there is contact/altering the play.

That is why I have a hard time telling someone not to call the FPSR as written unless there is alteration/contact. What if we let a FPSR call go, then a week later the same kid has a FPSR called on him, after he trashes some kid's knee? I have a former D1 player in my umpire's class this year whose career ended because someone trashed his ACL on a FPSR violation (in an NCAA game).

I would like to see FED do a total rewrite of the rule, and maybe we on the web site can offer language to them to help clarify the problem.

Other comments?