Quote:
|
Originally Posted by PWL
The batter can haul it at any time. It's the defense that needs to know what play to make. The batter is never at a disadvantage in this situation. If he has any doubt in his mind, drop the bat and run.
|
By using a verbal "no catch" you're giving both the defense and the offense the heads up. It doesn't make sense that this mechanic is only for the benefit of the defense. I think this is especially true with the rule change that has the batter out as soon as he leaves the dirt circle surrounding homeplate. I guess it's true that the batter should run if he has any doubts in his mind, but why favor the defense when the catcher has the best idea of whether or not he fielded the ball cleanly.
Tim.