Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee
1) So.....if B1 hit the shooter across the wrists on the way up, and knocked the ball loose, you'd be inclined to completely ignore that? Remember, the basket didn't go in because of the foul.
|
You'd wave off the basket anyway, wouldn't you? Unless the ball leaves the shooter's hands before the charge, a rare case in situations which are in turn not very common. I believe there is no way B1 can foul A1, in such a way that A1 is not able to shoot, without setting A1 off balance.
Quote:
|
2) And neither was Juggling Referee saying to ignore the contact either. He said verbatim--"If A1 is pushed into B1, DON'T call the foul, but if there's a hack on the arm while A1 is going up and A1 charges right into B1, you should call it." Didn't you just basically kind of agree with him on both different situations?
|
I hope to have made clear my opinion.
Again, I'm not saying to ignore a foul: just call
the real foul, be it on A1 or B1. Or on both, if there is no other choice.
Ciao