Quote:
|
Originally Posted by HawkeyeCubP
decee, Scrapper, and Jurassic -
Sorry - I was not clear enough in my last post. The player (let's call him/her A3) I was envisioning (and not describing well enough by only saying "out of bounds status") was basically under the basket, one foot touching out of bounds, not facing the thrower (possibly performing whatever part of the press-break play they're responsible for - screening, getting out of the way, etc., as the thrower is gathering the ball following the made basket), and gets hit by an out of bounds pass (say on their arm) from thrower A1 that is intended for A2, who is also out of bounds, on the other side of the key.
I'm asserting that this player is also out of bounds, on the same (end)line as the thrower (as decee said), but that this is a throw-in violation by A under 9-2-10, similar in rationale to 4.35.2(b).
(I agree that the ball touching another A player who is completely out of bounds on an endline pass during the throw-in would not be a violation.)
|
Again, I disagree. R9-2-10, as you stated, refers to a
"throw-in pass". A
throw-in pass", by rule (7-6-1) is thrown directly
into the court, not along the end line. Rule 9-2-2 basically says the same thing. Iow rule 9-2-10 is not relevant or germane. When A1 is throwing the ball along the endline, that is a legal
pass under R7-5-7,
not a
throw-in. A3 was hit
OOB by a legal
pass. There isn't any violation extant that you can call that I know of when that happens.
If A3 had one foot OOB, then he was legally OOB and had OOB status too btw. Case book play 4.35.2(b) isn't relevant either. Rules 7-5-7 and 7-6-1 are.