Quote:
Originally posted by ChuckElias
Come on now, TH. Didn't we just have this conversation? I thought the concensus was that it's a T regardless of the contact. The reason was that the T is for the swinging, which has to come before any contact. So whether there's contact or not, you call the T.
Isn't that what we all decided?!?!?! I just called one (probably my first call of this type in the last 5 or 6 years), and I called a T specifically based on the discussion here. Frankly, I'm totally at a loss now. 
Chuck
|
Different play, Chuck.
We're not talking about a play were a player excessively swings his elbow. I took it that we're talking about an elbow to the chops that the player thinks no one will see. Two completely different situations.
If I misinterpreted the play, I'll stand corrected but that's what I understood to have happened.