[kentref]

Fourth and 10 for team K from its own 20 yard line. With K1's punt in flight, R2 and R3 give valid fair-catch signals. R2 muffs the kick, and the ball ricochets toward R3. As R3 is about to catch the kick he is tackled by K4.

The stated ruling is "holding on K4." The rule reference given is 6-5-6. Per 6-5-6 the prescribed penalty is for "kick catching interference."

6-5-6 also states that the prohibition against contacting R or obstructing R's path to the ball does not apply after a scrimmage kick has been touched by a receiver who was clearly beyond the neutral zone ....

The case play cited (6.5.6.E) would appear to contradict the Referee mag ruling.

IMO, once R touches it then K is free to contact R and attempt to gain possession.

Thoughts by others?