Quote:
|
Originally Posted by GarthB
Okay, I stand corrected. It's not your reading skill that's impaired. It's your reading comprehension skills that's impaired. BU did not state #2 as you claim. At least is his post above, nowhere does he say "IF" the umpire knows the rule. All he says is that they (umpires in his association) would advise of the rule.
Unless you are running for opffice, it's always better form to not change the statement you are debating.
|
You are, of course, correct. I was careless, and I apologize to Tim and you.
With your correction, I still believe that point 1 and position 2 are more in agreement than position 1 is with position 3.
(I could make an argument that adding the phrase didn't alter the logical value of the statement, but you have already rejected my mathematics credentials, so it would be a WoBW. And, of course, you were right.)