[BktBallRef]

Originally Posted by mcrowder

Gotcha.

I still don't think, in the OP, that the action described was illegal. But I'm going off his use of the word "Blocking". To me, if this block was not either in the back, exceedingly malicious, or below the waist, I'm having trouble seeing what one might call a personal foul. And if it was in the back or below the waist, we have different penalties than PF for this (not to mention that the OP's statement that the player was out of the play would no longer be a relevant part of the equation).

Too often I've seen a player who is supposedly "out of the play" suddenly become "in the play" again due to unforeseen circumstances, and since this DOES happen, we can't be too strict on blocking players supposedly "out of the play".

You're correct. You're not an NFHS expert. If you were, you'd be familiar with the POE's over the last few years. You'd be familiar with what HS officials are told at state and local clinics. This play is illegal and the Fed and the States want it called.

Stick with NCAA.