[Bob M.]

REPLY: Remember that the foul is for A returning to the field after being OOB--not for stepping OOB in the first place. If he returns (a) prior to the pass, or (b) during the pass, the foul occurred during a loose ball play and yankeesfan gave you the answer. If he returns after the pass is completed, then his foul occurred during a running play. Use the all-but-one principle to compare the basic spot (end of the run) and the spot of the foul (point where A returned).